Rated 4.6 out of 5 by 8
Rated 5 out of 5 by etphonehome This coat is perfect.
As can easily be seen by how quickly it sold out online, this coat is perfect. I am 5'1, wear an XS in the Tippi sweater, and a 4 in the fluted skirt, and the P4 is perfect.
October 12, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Crista Nice, but not as luxurious as advertised.
I ordered the carbernet color and it's lovely. The color is as advertised. The material-not so much! The 22% nylon is NOT mentioned (only 8% cashmere). The coat also has a slight diagonal pattern, which you cannot see in pictures displayed on the website. I sized up one, as I always do in J.Crew coats. I am so glad that petite sizes are available this season. I love the look of this coat, and I'll order another color if my size comes back in stock!
October 12, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by MandyTX The perfect coat
I don't usually write reviews but for this, I will make an exception. I like wool coats but hate hate hate the ones that are scratchy, but the nylon and cashmere in this coat blended with the wool is perfect - not scratchy!!! I'm 5'2" and 110 lbs and the P4 fits perfectly ( and I tried it on with a light sweater underneath) I have slightly long arms and the sleeves are still long enough. The ocean harbor color is soooo pretty. It's a darker jewel toned blue/ turquoise color, which is great because bright colors don't look good with my skin tone. Oh, and the lining gives it a fun touch. It's a medium blue with green piping- very cute. The one thing I would change is maybe adding an interior pocket, but other than that it's perfect.
November 14, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by LondonerInLove Wow!
This fits. Beautifully. Like it's been handmade for me. And it's soft but tough. And the colour is a real navy - rich and dark and black-blue. And the lining. I honestly don't know why the lining isn't in a picture online - it's beautiful.
As you can tell, there's nothing I don't love about this coat (I'm actually embarrassed to be gushing like this, but finding a petite coat that is stylish and well made is like finding the perfect jeans).
October 31, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by Jessica Fits nicely but too long
This trench fits true to size, I got my usual JCrew size – 00 Petite (5’1’, 100 lbs). I had it shortened by 3 inches though -- it hit a couple of inches above my knees and with the dramatic flare, it was not very flattering. The black color attracts a lot of lint but it is overall very warm and good quality – I do not have the wrinkling issues that some people are describing.
January 13, 2016