Rated 4.5 out of 5 by 10
Rated 5 out of 5 by Chipper Retro cool!
A polo shirt, for me, has always been kind of something I don't give much thought, as long as the fit is right and it's comfortable. In that regard, it's much like a t-shirt for me in the warmer months--something to throw on quick for a day at the pool or lounging around the house, and the like. This creature, however, is something a little more than an ordinary polo. It's because of the tipping and the nice, slim cut, both of which give it a kind of cool retro vibe reminiscent of something you might see in an old Bond movie from the 1960s or some kid wearing in a surfer movie. While it is slimmer cut, I'd say, than other J. Crew polo shirts, it is not so slim that it is uncomfortable, as there's plenty of room to move in and nothing cinches anywhere--it simply looks sleek and well-proportioned. I also really like the textured fabric. I own this in both the white and the navy. I plan on wearing these shirts as often as I can this summer.
May 31, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Graham Looks great, fits great
Bought in XL, I wear a 46L jacket, this polo is a great fit. Not to baggy and not skin tight. The fit highlights my shoulders, arms and chest but is still loose enough for me to move around in without feeling like I'm going to pull an incredible hulk and rip it if I bend down. Highly recommend!
April 15, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Rockhound Quality retro polo
I'm very happy with my purchase of this tipped polo in white. In medium, it fits slightly slimmer than J.Crew's non-slim pique and broken-in polos, but not substantially so. I find medium slim pique polos too slim, however this tipped polo is simply fitted.
I appreciate the well-proportioned chest pocket, the slight variable texture, and the fact that in white it isn't see-through despite the lightweight fabric. The tipped details add some retro appeal and but collar is of slim modern proportions. This polo goes great with J.Crew's chambray linen/cotton chinos. Recommended.
April 17, 2016
Rated 2 out of 5 by Rainmanjp Runs ridiculously small
Ugh - so frustrating that JCrew does not have a consistent policy around sizing
Purchased a large and fit more like a small - can this really be a men's shirt?
It looked more appropriately cut for a 12 year old boy
Regardless of the fit the material was thin and frankly I was so disappointed by yet again another sizing disparity with a JCrew product that I immediately returned it. If you happen to have an 8th grade boy in your household order him a large.
April 2, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Taufique Love the fit and the material.
The fit and material of these Polos are just perfect. JCrew should use these Polos as the guideline for all their other polos...not too tight or not too loose. Just perfect! I have 3 of these...white, blue and burgundy.
August 15, 2016