Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 21
Rated 2 out of 5 by 10023 Glorious fabric, awful fit
I was so excited when I saw the brown/white stripe - loved the color combo and the amazing fabric (just the right weight).
HOWEVER, the cut is really off. The body is very narrow and the armholes are huge. As a result of the enormous armholes, the cap sleeves don't sit right.
Wish they'd make this color combo in the painter tees - perfect cut!
5'2", 105lbs. XXS too tight in body with large-ish armholes; XS armholes insanely big but comfy in body.
May 20, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by kelder712 Really wanted to like it, but short
I bought this shirt, as well as a ballet cap sleeve tee in a solid color. The striped version is a full 1-1.5 inches shorter, which was so disappointing. I really wanted to love this shirt, and I do love the plain color version of it, but couldn't keep the striped version because it was too short. As reference, I am 5'7" and bought it in a M and it hit at high hip, while the plain colored version hit at my low hip, which is where I prefer.
May 5, 2016
Rated 2 out of 5 by JoJo Nice fabric and colors, poor fit
This t-shirt (both stripe and solid) is misadvertised as slim fit. It's anything but. It fits very large - similar to other reviewers I had to go down a size. J Crew slim fit normally means cut close to the body, with a waist that goes in. These are a very boxy cut, and while they fit close it the hips, the middle is very loose. I ended up having mine tailored to take them in at the waist. Also agree that the armholes are very big unless you go down in size.
Keep the fabric, but please fix the fit - or change the description from slim fit to a more accurate one. My preference would be fixing the fit so that it's truly slim fit. With the painter t-shirt apparently discontinued, the selection of slim fit t-shirts for those customers who still like them is very limited.
June 11, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Anna Perfection
I absolutely love these tees. I purchased them in 6 different colors. They are the perfect length and are not too tight or too loose. I have a very hard time finding tees that fit and are not so thin that they are see through and this is it!
June 1, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Onefineday Poor material
*washed gentle cycle only once and wore three times and big big holes afew holes already
*not very happy with material
May 14, 2016