Rated 4.1 out of 5 by 35
Rated 4 out of 5 by klnyc Punch of perfection
I own this lipstick in both colors, George and Parker, and am overall very impressed with the quality. It not only packs a great punch of color, but the texture is feather light and not cake-y like some of my other matte lipsticks. George is the perfect shade of red-orange. I found it to be more red than orange on my lips. The texture is neither drying nor hydrating – I dab lip balm on and go straight from the tube, I think it actually looks better that way. If you're looking to reproduce that famous J Crew pout, or if you're like me, and still looking for that HG red-orange, this one is pretty near perfect.
December 1, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by zoey crayon like
I love Jcrew. I really really do! This lipstick was a large fail, though. I understand the "orangey red" Jcrew signature color, but this is mostly orange. The texture is very odd - almost gritty and just sits on top of lips. It is beyond matte - more like a crayon texture. I've tried it three different times now because I wanted to at like it. Every time, I end up just wiping it off. So sad.
November 25, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Mande Beautiful color that lasts.
Love these lipsticks! I purchased both the Parker and George shades. The Parker is a beautiful shade of berry that can be layered for more pigment. I love the George shade. It is a gorgeous coral red and one application provides the perfect amount of color. The formula is matte but feels so smooth going on. If you like matte formula lipsticks, I highly recommend them.
December 4, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Bex29 I love you George
It is the perfect orange/red matte lipstick. Put it on as soon as it arrived and instantly felt put together. It takes very little to create a saturated lip. Stayed on well without smudging. Can't wait to experiment with a little gloss over it. While I love George, I have a thing for Bob too…he's on his way.
March 20, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by Lola Just bleh
I unfortunately purchased this lipstick in the BOB color thinking I was going to get this beautiful mauve-purplish hue...
Why bleh? For several reasons:
1. Too pricy way too expensive for what it is!
2. Cheap looking...The container looks sleek on the website...Not what I got!!
3. Poor quality product. VERY chalky. I understand it is matte but to have a product this chalky is gross!
4. Picture on the web site shows a MUCH darker hue...I got a much MUCH paler color on the lipstick something that a 13 years old girl would wear...Makes me look ridiculous...It's this PALE BUBBLEGUM PINK!!!YIKES!!!
5. Makes my lips go totally DRY!!! Sucks all the moisture out of my lips...Not sure what is in this lipstick but wow...
My humble advice, stay away!!!
I will not repurchase this again, you've got that right!!
April 21, 2015