Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 20
Rated 2 out of 5 by janer Too Much Stretch.
I've been buying Jcrew jeans for many years. This latest iteration is disappointing. The fabric has gone from 7% to 9% stretch and they now feel and fit like leggings. I wish Jcrew would make a slim jean (not a boyfriend cut) in traditional denim- with zero or only a little stretch. I love that the rise is finally going up (about time). Returning these.
September 10, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by Emma Wish Fabric was more jean-like
I love the matchstick cut, but I'm not really loving the Cone denim. It isn't denim, but a jeggings, stretchy kind of fabric that I don't really like because it seems to get baggy. I just miss real denim, but I did keep these because it's hard to find jeans that fit.
September 23, 2015
Rated 2 out of 5 by Jenny Thin, Faded, Too Stretchy
I've worn J.Crew matchstick jeans for years and loved them. I used to recommend them to everyone. Not these. The fabric is thin and very stretchy and the dark blue washed off of the thighs and hips after the first couple washes.
March 8, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by sally Hopeful
Well, I had bought these same pants 2 years ago. Love the fit, although they tend to stretch out in the waist area. But, I titled this hopeful, because my last pair looks like new after, say, 8 washings, except the knees look worn out and are almost white compared to the indigo color. They look like I spend a lot of time on my knees, which isn't the case. I think this just comes from stretching the knee fabric a bit when I sit. I usually don't buy the same product again when I'm not satisfied, but am optimistic in this case.
October 17, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Gail The perfect pair of jeans
These jeans are seriously the best pair I have ever owned. I am 5'10, 134 pounds and it has always been difficult to find jeans that fit well. These jeans have the perfect amount of stretch for comfort and look great on as well. The length is good. They are fitted enough below the knee to tuck into below-the-knee boots, but still roomy enough to be comfortable. I like the slim look without the "legging" look of the skinny-fit denim. Excellent product...I bought two more pairs after I wore my first pair!
December 26, 2015