Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 18
Rated 4 out of 5 by Michelle Awkward style
This coat looked beautiful coming out of the box. I usually wear a size 4 in J.Crew tops, and I sized up to a size 6 to fit over blazers. The fit was perfect, and the fabric is really nice and seems warmer than the double-cloth. Sadly, this is going back. The style of the coat was not very feminine or flattering on me, and I had trouble with the zipper, which didn't seem very high-quality. Also, the metals are most definitely rose-gold in person, not yellow as they are in the picture, if that matters.
November 17, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by Sarah Wanted to LOVE it
I really wanted to love this coat, but the zippers are a rose gold not the yellow gold that it looks like in all pictures of the coat. Very disappointed and sending back! The jacket is also very thin and doesn't feel like it'd be very warm. Also, if you have any curves, I felt it just bulked me up around the waist!
November 12, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by salsacat Disappointing Cut
I wanted to like this coat but cut is boxy almost like cocoon style. There is no shoulder seem and there is no waist shaping seem on the back( seems run straight up and down on the back) so it looks boxy over all. Quality and construction is pretty good though. Even with belt tied around there is a double layer of fabric in front of the body so it makes it looks balky…I am 5'1 and 130 lb. Got P6 length was bit long below my knee cap, slightly long on my arm. P6 fit well though with light weight sweater under.
November 18, 2015
Rated 2 out of 5 by minibell Weird fit
I agree with the other reviewers, that the hardware is more of a rose gold in color, and the zipper gave me a lot of trouble. I'm a size 2 in J.Crew blazers, and a 2-4 in their pants, and found that this coat in a size 2 was quite large on me. It didn't nip in at the waist at all, and was very bulky under the belt. It was really unflattering and not of the quality I expected - it's definitely going back!
November 17, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by JessDC Just doesn't work
I purchased the Navy in 4P and really wanted to love this coat -- the materials and everything are beautiful, but the fit was just off. There is no seaming in the coat, so it creates a bunchy, baggy look around the waist when belted. No girl wants her waist to look bigger! I considered just ditching the belt and wearing it as a "cocoon style" coat, but it just wasn't worth it for the price.
December 5, 2015