Rated 3.3 out of 5 by 3
Rated 4 out of 5 by EnvyNE Great skirt
I love this skirt. Great fabric for fall and just enough detail to be a great update to your black pencil skirt for fall/ winter. Runs a little small. I am between 0 and 2 in Jcrew pencil skits and went with 0. It hugs curves in all the right places which l wanted with this skirt. 2 would have been ok- just wouldn't have that made for you fit.
Highly recommend if you are looking for a black pencil skirt with just a little twist in detail to make it stand out. Can't wait to wear this one. Great quality too!
August 23, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by shopdiva Okay for a different pencil skirt
I'm a big fan of the double serge pencil skirts from a few years ago( this years version is higher in the waist). I wanted this skirt for something different than my regular go to black pencil skirt. Fabric is okay for a cotton tweed blend. This fit is snugger in the hip than other pencil skirts and I feel like the waist is alot higher as well. I ordered my regular 6T ( i'm only 5'5 but the reg. is too short) but it was so high on my waist and tight it was uncomfortable. I just reordered in a reg 8 since tall is sold out. I'm hopeful but maybe returning that one was well. I"m hate that the fit changes year by year. J Crew use to be more consistent and a go to for high quality work attire.
September 21, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by michellek Not for me
Not impressed with this skirt. It would look nice if the quality was higher (it's a cotton tweed "texture" rather than a real tweed - reminds me of a velvety couch cushion). The fringe on the bottom looks cheap. A petite 2 was too big on me, contrary to what the size chart indicated (I wear a 26 in jeans).
September 16, 2016