Rated 4.2 out of 5 by 18
Rated 2 out of 5 by Jill Disappointing
I had high hopes for this tunic. When I saw the berry melange color online, I just had to have it. It sold out so fast that I hunted it down in a store. Unfortunately, that colour is not nearly as lively looking in real life. The "melange" part is not really visible in the online picture and it really makes it dull looking. Dowdy. The sleeves are snug per the style and the rest of the top falls in a true tunic style. It is not tremendously oversized like some other tunics jcrew has had. I would say order your normal jcrew size.
It's not a really wide boatneck, which is nice.
It is soft, but maybe the ribbed style made it feel more like a cashmere blend than 100% cashmere.
It just seemed to look very frumpy though, and the colour that I wanted was a total disappointment. For that reason, I will not be keeping it. Other things are nicer at Jcrew for the money.
August 28, 2015
Rated 2 out of 5 by LuzLena Just Okay...
I should have listened to the first reviewer. This tunic was very soft and I actually really liked the colour in person. It wasn't as bright, but it was certainly deep and luxurious looking.
But, after putting it on, it left something to be desired. It is rather boxy and frumpy looking. Unless I keep my arms to my sides, it literally hangs out and away from my body like a box shape. Tucking it slightly or holding your arms against your body make it look better but I can't think of anyone but a soldier that does that all day. I'm 5'1", 26 waist, 34 around chest (32 under breasts), and 34 hip for my measurements. It fell to my hips. I think smaller cup sizes might look significantly better in this than I did.
September 14, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Rebecca In love!
I recently bought this sweater despite all of the subpar reviews and when it came in the mail I have to say that I disagree with them. Yes the color (berry) is slightly darker and richer than what you see online but it is still beautiful. The sweater is slightly oversized but doesn't look frumpy. I got my usual size S and it fits perfect. The cashmere is super soft and very warm with the perfect thickness, not too thick not too thin.
October 2, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jacey Perfect fall sweater
Although this sweater runs a bit big, I preferred it that way (perfect to wear with leggings). The 3/4 length sleeves are perfect and the boatneck opening is flattering. I bought this sweater in 3 colors after I felt how soft the cashmere was -- this will be a staple in my fall wardrobe.
September 16, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by cyng Perfectly YUMMY
I love every J. Crew cashmere sweater I own. The quality and style is what keeps me coming back. Beautiful cashmere that never piles, fades or looses it's shape. I highly recommend!
October 22, 2015