Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 35
Rated 5 out of 5 by JessicaAsh5 Adorable twist on a staple!
Ladies, go buy this top! And J Crew, PLEASE make this in more colors! This top is so much more flattering than the last version with the bigger ruffles. The smaller ruffles on this version are much better and don't make my arms look huge. I LOVE the blue color! If I had one negative thing to say, I would point out that it's a tad short for my taste but that's more a personal thing (it hits just above the hips). Other people might like that.
July 12, 2016
Rated 2 out of 5 by Cathy Not a keeper
I wanted to love this top. The concept is great. And I agree with the other reviews that the ruffle on the sleeve is just right. But for me I had to return.
It runs small. I am a size 8 and ordered the large and it was very fitted.
But the biggest problem with this top is that it is too short. Can't tuck it in to stay, and too short to sit nice on the hips. Should have been an inch or two longer.
July 16, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by Trojan Fitted thick Tee
The tee is fitted with thick enough material to wear without a tank/cami under it. I am 5'2" 102lb, and the length of XXS is just right for a petite person. I was worried that it is too short after reading the other reviews.
July 23, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by eggroll82 Great basic with a twist
I was so sad when last season's striped ruffled sleeve shirt sold out. I think this version is better though. However, I think there are a couple of things to keep in mind before ordering this shirt. I'm usually a PXXS/PXS - 5'2", 32C-23-33. I ordered the regular XS (petite sizes are not available) and it fits well in the shoulders and chest. It's a little boxy through the waist but it's not a deal breaker. It is a good length on my short height so I can imagine how it would be short on someone taller. The quality is great and I believe it will wash well.
July 27, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Julie A winner!
Finally, a J Crew purchase I'm keeping! I'd pretty much given up on J Crew because, with most of the items I'd ordered lately, I felt the quality had gone downhill, or the fit was off. This tee fit perfectly, cut just right in all the places, including the neckline, and is not too long or too short. The fabric is not as heavy (and uncomfortable) as its predecessor but is substantial enough that I think it will retain its shape after washing. The sleeves are really cute. Hope this is a sign of return to the old J Crew.
July 19, 2016