Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 34
Rated 1 out of 5 by Lauren One Use
Very disappointed in this. I received this in the mail recently along with the matching shell. I wore it for the first time yesterday to work and when I got home it looked like I've had worn this for 10 years. Its already pilling and looks worn. I will not be able to wear this again. Very disappointed as it was an expensive piece that I want to get some wear out of. Already wore it so can't return it. Will not buy any of J Crews cashmere pieces again.
February 26, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by noodlegirl Bring back the old fit and quality
I've been buying these for several years; adding new colors each Spring. I used to love this sweater, as well as the other JCrew cashmeres.... but the love affair is over! The 2016 version is smaller, more sheer, and not as soft. My usual size- XS, was tooooo small (5'1" 100#). I ordered several online, and only kept two. We'll see how these work out. I've noticed similar changes with your other collection cashmeres ....not good!!! Please give us back the sweaters and quality we love! We don't mind paying more..... REALLY!
April 18, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by sakura New Version Poor Quality!
I used to love this sweater. I'd buy it each season in different colors & wear them year round as a winter layer or a summer shield against aggressive AC. It was a perfect classic.
But I ordered 2 new colors (sunset pink & vintage pink) and was SO DISAPPOINTED. They are supposed to be lightweight, but this season's fabric is much thinner, transparent and NOT SOFT like the old ones! It didn't even seem to be cashmere. The buttons were larger & not as delicate.
Why, why, why JC have you downgraded this PERFECT sweater? So sad to see an old favorite die. At least this may be a cure for my expensive cashmere sweater habit...
April 8, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Avagirl J. Crew, are you listening??
This is not the first season that J.Crew has been criticized for the declining quality of their featherweight cashmere. I have featherweight cardigans from 5+ years ago that are in much better shape than the couple I bought last year. Inexcusable. The price is high; the quality is not. Your customers want a quality garment and are clearly willing to pay for it. Please deliver.
May 27, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by Susie Too Sheer and Lightweight
Tried on the Heather Neon Flamingo cardigan over a white cami in store. I typically wear a small but needed the medium. It's a beautiful color and looked great in the dressing room, but when I got it home, I realized how sheer and lightweight it really was. I was concerned it would not wear well, so I returned it for the merino wool cardigan in a similar color.
February 3, 2016