Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 10
Rated 2 out of 5 by ForeverForty So much potential . . .
I loved this shirt - opened the packaging to a beautiful color, great fabric, loved the placket. I imagined the number of ways I could wear it . . . until I put it on. The sleeves are extremely awkward, sticking straight out, and make the whole thing look odd. I'm so disappointed.
May 12, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Corgyngirl Crisp and cool shirt for humid summer days!
This is a beautiful shirt- lovely crisp poplin fabric in a great design. This top is a bargain considering the quality. The pale oxford blue fabric has a micro tiny cross hatch weave that steps up the quality beyond your typical blue oxford. The color is gorgeous-as soon as I put this on my husband told me he LOVED my top and the color. The popover placket with single button is demure yet cool. The sleeves are great- just the right amount of coverage for the work place. I experienced no problems with the sleeves sticking out- my top looks just like the photo. Would gladly buy this in other colors! Fits true to size- took my usual size 4 (34DD).
May 18, 2015
Rated 2 out of 5 by Katie Better suited for small busted ladies!
I ordered this shirt with the hope it could be a good work shirt...sadly the style and fit did not work for me. As a larger chested lady (!), the shirt did not flatter my bust and pulled quite a bit, however going up a size would have resulted in the rest of the shirt being too large. I would recommend this shirt for those with smaller chest as you would not have a pulling/gaping issue! Also, I was not a fan of the one button. It looked a bit cheap and out of place...it probably would have looked better without or with a flap of fabric over it.
December 4, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by VIKKI Old Hollywood
Wow!! I just got this "Old Hollywood" style Short- Sleeve Popover Shirt in Oxford Blue.I felt like a movie star when I slipped it on. The fit is perfect, very sleek and classic. I paired it with straight legged cropped khakis. Hats off to you J Crew you did it again!! Thank you!!
June 6, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by Jennifer19 Great style, poor quality
Loved the style and bought one in blue stripe, too. I washed it once (and let air dry) prior to a weekend getaway and the buttons are now loose and falling off. The shirt looks nice but, as with a lot of J.Crew clothing, the quality isn't there. I keep trying with clothing but end up with the same result - poor quality because of cut corners. Not surprised by slipping sales and reputation and frustrated about the money I wasted. Don't waste yours.
April 17, 2016