Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 5
Rated 5 out of 5 by susieshoesy Perfect Fit
J. Crew Toothpick jeans are amazing. I bought my usual size and they fit perfectly. They do not stretch much, if at all. They are my go-to jeans and I have them in many colors. I am 5'7" and prefer the tall sizing because the jeans go fully to my ankles.
April 24, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Marisa Love these jeans!
I'm 6ft and the Tall size are long enough. They have great stretch and keep their shape. I have several pairs in different colors.
October 7, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by Emma Far better than the old version
The old version of the classic rinse toothpick jeans 2013 were terrible... I had SEVERAL pairs, all of which tore in the exact same spot more than 6 times. The cone denim pair I recently bought in Nov 2014 are vastly superior quality, though they have faded considerably after 3 wears and no wash. I'm a little sad to wash them tonight, as I know the colour will totally change... But they're not premium denim... So for the price, I'm happy.... Much happier than I was with last years model.
December 17, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Srrdnam These will make great dressy jeans!
These jeans have a nice dark rinse and are well fitted without being too constraining or causing the ever dreaded muffin top. They make great dressy jeans for a night out.
I don't have super skinny legs so if you are athletic or have more than just chicken legs these jeans will work for you.
December 21, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by Joto Not the right fit
These jeans are not a good fit for a curvy person. I am 5'10" and take either a size 8T or 10T in J Crew pants, depending on the cut, and usually a 30 in jeans. I carry some weight in my thighs, but they aren't massive. I tried these in a 31. The thighs are tight, the waist is loose, the rise is too low. Over the course of the day, the entire pant slides downward. I have to have a belt cinched very tightly in order to keep them from working their way down into a drop-crotch jean. I also don't like the fake wear on the backside. The butt and upper thighs are much lighter, sort of a highlight, and not in a flattering way. I keep trying J Crew jeans and keep being disappointed.
March 14, 2016