Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 15
Rated 3 out of 5 by enc1 Lovely, but sheer
I ordered this in the oatmeal heather (beige) color.
It felt and looked lovely, and it fit very well. However, it's very sheer. I had a beige t-shirt bra on underneath it when I tried it on, and it was clearly visible beneath the top. If you don't mind sheer, it'll be fine. But if you're concerned about modesty, this might not be the top for you.
February 2, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by jec79 great shirt - until you wear it
I was a little disappointed in this T as I had super high hopes for it, and bought several. I am sold on anything cashmere, and since I am TOTALLY NOT a Tshirt person, I was excited for a "nice" t-shirt that was a bit above average. I ended up sizing up to a L from my usual M as the M was very snug and showed every bump on my midsection. At home, the L fit great. However, as I went through the day, it stretched out so much it was a baggy, sloppy mess. The thinness of the T doesn't bother me (but you do need a cami under unless you're ok with your bra showing through). One the first wear, the fabric did slightly snag on the first wear. I'm happy I only took tags off one, and not the three I bought. The rest will be going back. Unfortunate, because it has a lot of potential and for the price (even at a discount), it's not worth it. Bummer.
April 17, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by ShoppyPants Wonderful tee but agree-- sleeves are too short.
This feels amazing. It's so soft and definitely luxurious. I usually wear XS in J.Crew tees but I wanted this one a bit more loose like shown on the model so I ordered a Small. However, I'm athletic (5'6/130 lbs) and not a model; therefore this shirt actually fits me like a slim fit. I still love it, but I will go with Medium if I want a casual look. The tee has a wonderful scoop cut neck and has a subtle sheerness that I find perfect. I agree: the sleeves are an odd length! They fall at least 4 inches above my wrist too and therefore I also push them up. I would rate this shirt a 5 star if the sleeves were fixed to be longer.
March 17, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by Shanudy Lovely drape...
It is a bit sheer but in a good way, subtle sheerness with just a suggestion of bra color. The sleeves are a bit of an odd length I have to wear them pushed up if I leave them down they fall about four inches above my wrist bone.
February 11, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by Alexandria Very Lightweight but Sizing is off
The last few items I have purchased in their T-Shirt style - from their 100% lightweight cashmere T to these long sleeve shirts - all have been at least one full size too small. Basically any summer-weight top is now one full size too small and in many cases their Fall and Winter items are one full size too big. I don't mind having to size up or down but it is VERY annoying when a company seemingly has very inconsistent sizing on the items. Some of them I have purchased at Final Sale thinking they would fit my "normal" size and have been unable to wear or return because of the sizing inconsistencies.
I originally purchased two of these in XS and am heartbroken they are both too small. I love the feel of this shirt, how lightweight, soft and sheer it is but will have to go through the trouble of exchanging (if the colors are still available) for a larger size. Ugh.
April 22, 2016