Rated 5 out of 5 by Vancouvergirl Cute dressy tank
This is a nice, somewhat dressier and more interesting alternative to a basic tank. The trim, slits, and tie are all terrific features that add something extra. As the model photo would indicate, this is a straight or even slightly A-line shape, so if you’re looking for a more body-conscious fit, you might consider ordering a size down. I’m a size 6, for reference 5’5”, bust 36C, waist 28, and I found the Small fits loose, looser than shown on the model. I probably could have gone with the XS if I wanted it to look a little more shapely. The fit is also longer (at least, on me) than it appears on the model. The navy version dresses up my denim shorts, denim skirt, and white jeans. Glad I purchased this!
May 14, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by Serene Looks great on the model
I bought this top because of the cute trim around the edging--top and bottom. It's as cute as can be on the model, but it didn't work for me, because the sides of the bust gaps out and is noticeable. I thought of ordering down one, but did not because it wouldn't have made any difference. Maybe under a blazer it wouldn't matter, but I bought it to wear casual. Sorry I had to return this one.
May 29, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by Flowers Cute...but...
I sized down because my usual size was too big. I tried the navy..the color is great and I love the edging detail. But...the little slits on the side are too high. They show some skin and it just doesn't look right. I also couldn't really figure out what to do with the tie at the front so it looked cute...
Unlike a lot of the shirts...the v isn't too low bc this style is more fitted.
June 1, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by scgal Cute but arm holes are HUGE
Oh I loved this top. Perfect for a hot southern summer. Material is soft and thin enough for summer yet thick enough to have body to hold up all day long. Trim is very cute. Could dress it up or down. BUT - the arm holes were super large and showed almost all of the side of my bra. A little peek of bra here & there is kinda cute for a casual top, but this is just too much. Had an alterations guy look at taking them in, but it would have thrown off the whole fit. So I had to return it. What are you thinking, JCrew?
June 20, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by MDTeach If not for the huge armholes...
There are so many things to love about this top - the fabric is nice and thick, the trim is really pretty, the quality is great all around, and the style is perfect for summer with shorts, white jeans, etc. However, as other reviewers have stated, the armholes are HUGE. Huge as in not only the top of my bra shows, but the bottom shows too when I move, though the top is the correct size and I couldn't size down and still have it fit everywhere else. In addition to showing my bra, the area next to the arm holes poofs out, as if it should have darts to make it lay flat on the bust. I bought it on super sale, so I am going to keep it and wear it with a camisole underneath. I am just hoping that I don't pull at it continually in an effort to get it to lay as it should. It is an adorable top, and it is really unfortunate that something as avoidable as a poor design of the armholes on this simple tank makes it a miss.
July 31, 2016