I'm 5ft, 120lbs, 27" waist, 25" inseam. The sweater feels really heavy and substantial. The material seems really high quality. It's less itchy than other cashmere but still itchy. I was able to wear it with a shirt underneath. However, the style is really odd. The body of the sweater hits above the waist, but the sleeves are at least 6 inches longer than the body, and is almost as wide. It does look odd and not as flattering. I wish the body was 4 inches longer and the sleeves are shorter and not as wide. It's not returnable and I'm trying to make it work but it's disappointing. It's a shame because the material is nice otherwise.

A great collection sweater! Similar to other reviews and the sizing it’s cropped at 18”. I’m 5’2 with a shorter torso so it works for me. Definitely recommend if you have a shorter torso or want a cropped look. It’s a thicker nice quality cashmere knit from their other cashmere sweaters which I love!

Very, very cropped. I even sized up and it’s still too cropped.

This is so thick and warm, I love this sweater! I sized up to get a bit more length in the body and it is perfectly cropped. Can't wait to wear it in the Fall!

Gorgeous sweater characteristic of all J.Crew's thick and heavy cashmere. The description indicates 18" length which is very cropped for a sweater, and was concerning, but the weight compensates for the length and the sweater does not at all feel too short, for reference, 5'4", 147". In brushed cashmere I consistently downsize from M to XS but only S was available and that was the right size, considering the length. A big J.Crew sale was too good not to purchase both colors and so glad I did as I will live in them this Winter.

Great quality and style, wish more were like this.