Rated 4.7 out of 5 by 54
Rated 5 out of 5 by OAYB Versatile. Comfortable. Classic.
High quality suede in colors that match just about any item of clothing and look. I've owned my pair for over a year and the construction has held up nicely. Overall fit, in my opinion, is a bit generous and the shoe will naturally break in or stretch over time. I'd recommend sizing down a half size to compensate for this. I've worn these with jeans, shorts, sweat pants and summer suits, always comfortably. A great staple piece of footwear.
May 16, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by DJGreen Love them! My new faves!
Finally bought these after pining for them for a long time. I got the Anchor Grey, and they are kind of more taupe-ish. I'd say the color is one of those that looks a bit different depending on the lighting. I still like them though because it's a pretty versatile color. Also, I usually wear an 8 in women's sizing, but sometimes 7.5. I decided to size down and got a men's 5.5, which was a good idea because they fit perfectly, so if you're in between sizes go for the smaller one. In my opinion they look good with any style pants pretty much. Not sure about wearing them with skirts yet, but maybe with leggings or opaque tights.
June 6, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by AnnieC45 A Woman's Perspective
Awesome! This is the first time ever that I purchased a Men's style and downsized to a 7.5 (Woman's 10). These don't make my feet appear larger or wider and definitely comfortable from the start. So stylish! Thanks J. Crew!
May 15, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by DBandKN Perfect casual boots
My boyfriend and I got these and we love them. I bought the anchor grey color a few months back and sized down 2 from w11 to m9 but they were huge [and got sent back] so I was skeptical the second time around. I decided to go down an extra size from a womens 11 to a mens 8.5 and it is a perfect fit. There is still a little space in the toe and I have wide feet so they're a good, supportive snug. My boyfriend usually wears an 11.5 so he got an 11 and they are perfect for him too. The grey wasn't my favorite so we got stone... which is a little less yellow than the picture and is a goregous grey-khaki color. I love them already and can hardly wait to wear them. Don't cheat yourself. Go for it. The "dark khaki" is almost like a reddish cognac color... those are my next bet. I can't wait! Thanks JCrew :)
July 25, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sp326 Finally bought them!
I have wanted a pair of J Crew Macalister boots forever, but I never could seem to find my women's shoe size in the men's sizing (always sold out). Finally found them now (maybe b/c it's summer and it's off season) and so I could not resist. I tried both size Men's 5 and 5.5 (I am a women's 7.5). The Men's 5 fit me best. Beautiful suede leather, soft on feet and I think will age well. Won't be able to wear these much until the fall, but looking forward to doing so!
June 5, 2014