Rated 3.4 out of 5 by 8
Rated 3 out of 5 by Meg326 Great style, poor quality
My fiance saw this sweater and bought it immediately. Unfortunately after a few wears (and no washes) the elbow patch on one arm started to come off. JCrew replaced it so we will see how the next one holds up. Seems to be a trend with JCrew lately, great styling, terrible quality :-/
January 8, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by ItsMe Better than expected!
I absent mindedly wrote this review originally for the non slim-fit version. Apologies, J. Crew. I ordered the Heather Graphite and the Heather Atlantic both in a size medium. There was no competition, though, as the Graphite looks even better in reality. I was told the chest circumference was 39.5" but it's more like a 38" on the grey. An interesting thing I've learned about purchasing clothes in the U.S. is that two items of the same size and colour or varying colour fit very differently which is why I always try on more than one of the same size. This is the case here where the blue colour has a longer sleeve and body length meaning that the elbow patches were mostly on the backs of my forearms and the sweater covered a great deal of the top half of my pants. The grey fits like it was knitted exactly for my measurements. The texture is amazing and non-irritating enough to wear on bare skin. Overall, great looking and fitting sweater!
November 26, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by disappointed Elbow Patch was not sewn on
Bought this sweater for my husband for Christmas and when he put it on the wear for the first time, we noticed one of the elbow patches was only half way sewn on, and it was left flapping around...
We love jcrew clothes but were so disappointed in the quality of this sweater...
January 9, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by Scott quality down hill
I recently bought 2 of these sweaters, 1 in red chily and 1 in heather atlantic and returned both after only the 1st wear as both got holes in the fabric/sweater, I am very disappointed with this product.
December 31, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by chelloveck Lots of compliments
Gotten good feedback wearing this sweater. Not too itchy. I wish the fabric wouldn't make pilling (tiny fabric balls) after only wearing it 2 times. A little snug in the wrong areas.
September 28, 2014