Sherpa flats with elastic

Trust the other reviews this shoe is really tight around the top part of your foot. Such a shame because it’s a really nice shoe that goes with a lot.

I agree with other reviewers, shoes run small. I’m size 5 in flats and ordered 6 and it fits perfectly, so I’d go 1 size up. Otherwise great shoe that I’ll enjoy wearing

I agree with the other reviewer that it's a bad feeling to order final sale shoes and discover that the sizing is way off normal. These are great looking shoes, but I can't wear the pair I received. Nevermind that I have ordered dozens of JCrew shoes over the years and know what the sizing should be. Luckily I was able to buy a size larger and I hope that they will fit correctly.

I bought these on a whim when they went on sale and actually liked the look of them so much better in person. The leather lining is soft and the exterior sherpa is fluffy and cozy; however, the soles are flat and hard with no support. I would probably wear these to a casual meet up with friends, but not all day or around the house (slippery and loud flat soles on hardwood floors). Unfortunately the shoes don’t fit me. They’re too tight across the top and the opening digs into my foot. I tend to wear a 9.5 in J.Crew and I bought my usual size. I’m not sure that sizing up would help since the shoe fit everywhere else. I have an average to slightly wide foot. These might work better for someone with a narrow foot. I’m thinking about taking them to a cobbler and asking them to make the opening wider.

These are definitely the tightest/smallest of many J.Crew shoes I have owned over the years... Difficult to put on b/c they're just so tight overall: narrow, seem a little short, and the top is just too snug (pass right on by these if you have even a remotely high arch). For shoes that look like they should be super snugly and comfortable, I feel like these are almost deceptive and disappointing. I got them as Final Sale, so I guess I'll try stretching them out to make them bearable, but otherwise I'd return them in a heartbeat.

These are very comfortable but they look more like slippers than shoes. I plan to wear them in the house. They do run a bit small.