Secret Wash organic cotton poplin shirt
Fits slightly small based on
- Regular fit.
- A more traditional full cut, roomier in the body and sleeves.
Reviews
Fits slightly small based on
12 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 12 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Customers generally praised the quality and refreshed design of the 100% cotton shirts, noting the soft texture, vibrant colors, and fun patterns that make them a great versatile addition to any wardrobe. Many long-time customers appreciated the thoughtful changes compared to previous versions, such as improved sleeve length for a more comfortable look. Some customers suggested trying different sizes as the new slim cuts with narrower sleeves may require adjustments for a comfortable fit. Overall, the shirts remain a stylish, easy-care option that continues to evolve based on customer feedback.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
bubba0804
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Size Purchased: sFits true to size
Great look and feel
January 28, 2026Shirt is of excellent quality and arrived as appears. Love that I can wash these and not dry clean. Great shirt for work.
Helpful?aaron86
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Fits true to size
Great summer shirt
December 4, 2024Love this shirt, the pattern is fun and it feels cool during summer.
Helpful?Kris
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'11"Size Purchased: Large inFits small
Shirt looks great but doesn’t fit
September 14, 2022The sizing of J Crew shirts has become unpredictable. In a six month period, I’ve purchased half a dozen of the slim fit shirts in the same size; all fit perfectly except this one. I’m disappointed enough to not bother looking at J Crew online anymore because the attention to uniform sizing — which should be a given in online sales — is gone. When I took it to my local bricks and mortar store, the clerk said too bad and suggested that I gift it or sell it. That’s too bad for this customer of 30+ years.
Helpful?Michael
Size Purchased: LargeFits small
Super narrow sleeves
September 1, 2022I have liked the Secret Wash shirts for years and have many hanging in my closet. They fit great. But the sleeves on these new shirts are so narrow that it feels like my forearms are going to start popping the seams. (I see that other reviewers have had the same issue.) I am not a super muscular guy either. Unless you have really thin arms, these arms are going to be uncomfortably tight, especially if you roll them up. And the rest of the shirt fits as normal—so the problem won’t be solved by simply going up a size. Then the rest of the shirt would be too big. I’m sad to say that I just won’t be able to buy any more of these shirts until they change this.
Helpful?Andy
Age: 55 to 64Body type: AthleticHeight: 6'1"Size Purchased: LargeFits true to size
Very nice looking shirt
August 5, 2022The texture of the fabric is soft. I love the fit. The color pops out. I am noticed in a crowd!
Helpful?Chris_
Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'10"Size Purchased: LargeFits small
Sleeves are too narrow.
July 29, 2022I like these shirts except for the discomfort in rolling up the sleeves. The sleeves are too narrow and feel tight when trolled up. So if you're athletic or lift weights don't buy these. Depending on who JCrew assigns to make their shirts, you may not get consistency. It's unfortunate when the shirts are charged at the price they ask for.
Helpful?