Rated 3.3 out of 5 by 3
Rated 2 out of 5 by Kerry Wide & Baggy
Ordered these shorts cause I have a few other pairs of dock shorts (which I love) & thought I'd like them in cotton. The cotton shorts are a much different fit than the chino dock shorts! While the waist is much softer (& a lot nicer) and the JCrew quality is still there - the fit is much more baggy & wide-legged. These shorts have a lot of excess material which I do not like. If you really want to try them maybe get a size down from your normal, but I'm sure they will still be a baggy fit.
August 2, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by John Easy cut
The cut is superior to the chino 'dock short', with an easier waist and narrower leg. I wear a medium and purchased a small. They could be improved with better colors, deeper pockets and matching drawstring.
July 7, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by busch laidback - runs slightly large - can improve
I love the fabric of these shorts. The overall fit is a little large. I ordered both a small and medium; the small was slightly snug, but fit (I'm a 34 waist, which I was surprised), and the medium fit well, but the opening is very wide. However, I kept both of them because they're super comfortable and easy to throw on.
If J.Crew added a zipper to the front - for when us guys use the water closet, it would be great! Also, the fabric in a Stanton Short? Yes, please!
August 28, 2016