Rated 3.1 out of 5 by 9
Rated 3 out of 5 by Marni123 fit problems for 34 A
I adore the look of this top but it is cut for a bigger chest. At 34A, 5'7", 120 pounds, on me the straps on the small sagged hugely. Completely unworkable. I could not take an XS as the girth would have been too tight. I probably would need the straps about 1 1/2 inches shorter to give this top the needed snugness and look like the model. I hope it would look smashing on someone who fills out the straps more. Interestingly the one-piece version with similar straps works for me though I found the sizing inconsistent on that suit between colors.
May 10, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by Lillian Runs very large!
Ordered the grey in size small (34B 5'9" 125lb) and it is swimming (no pun intended!) on me! The straps are too long and without some tension nor padding everything sags. Additionally, the actual cup area is too wide - the material comes off my body to the side a good inch. I'm returning and ordering a XS as I love the style. Quality-wise, this suit would be better if the band had a hook and thick loop, if the straps were adjustable, and if it were lined. I know they're thick straps, but I'm pretty sure you could maintain the style while achieving adjustability.
June 6, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by Lauren Interesting top
Even in plain black, with the thick bands this top is different and eye catching. I'm 5'6, 36a, broad shouldered, the small is a bit loose but I'm going to keep it because it's super comfortable. Its a shame there is not thicker lining or removable pads.
May 10, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by kmasher So cute but so unfortunate
This is a cute style but the sizing is just so unfortunate. I'm 5'10, 137 lbs, 34C. I ordered a small and XS. The XS is just slightly too small in the cup but very too small around. The small is right around but too big in the cup. The other problem, and I hope JCrew can help here in the future, is that there is no padding or support. At 44, post baby, I need more help than this offers. Even just a lining so that people can't tell when you are cold would be an improvement.
June 28, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by Shortmeg Size down.
I read reviews and was hesitant to purchase. It was clearanced at final sale, so for so cheap I took a chance. If it didn't work I wouldn't be out much. I'm 5'7", 125 lbs, 34D. I got the medium as that was the smallest size left. It fits better than what I was expecting. It looks like the model image. It's not skin tight and drapes at the shoulders and sides nicely and covers my breast while still looking very sexy. It would probably fit better in a small. But I'm happy with my purchase. If small become available I might purchase it for giggles. With that said, I don't think anyone with small breasts or narrow shoulders would be happy in this piece no matter how small the size was...
FYI The matching bottoms I purchased in a small and they fit perfectly
July 18, 2016