Rated 4 out of 5 by 12
Rated 2 out of 5 by mrswhitsker not a classic pique polo
I was happy to finally see polos for women again. I've been buying men's since I can't find any decent ones for women. To me, the photo makes the fabric look like it will be a washed down version of a classic pique polo but when it arrived I was disappointed. I got the white, and the fabric was very thin with almost no texture, and the sizing is very small, compared to other jcrew tops-like maybe 2 sizes smaller. I'm returning it.
June 15, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Coreen1111 Kids shirt?!
This is ridiculously grossly small! I got my usual XS (5'0, 105 lbs, 34B) and could barely get it on, and when I did it was a good laugh! There is no draping or looseness to it anywhere! I looked stuffed into it! The pale aqua is a gorgeous color, but if I were to have this fit as I liked I think I would need a large! What a disappointment.
June 14, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by TxTime Nice Polo
I usually wear a medium and that works for me in this top. I am fairly busty so it is a close thing but a large wouldn't work. It's a very classic fit. Just a word of warning-I got red and it is orange. Maybe a cool orange but not red. Luckily I like orange.
June 14, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by TorontoModern Definitely need to size up - great value on sale
J Crew sizing is so inconsistent. If the clothes were not so great I would have washed my hands of J Crew by now because of the sizing headaches. I typically wear an XS (Tippi, Vintage t shirt) and a Small Painter Tee (finding the XS painter too snug for my personal taste). But I wear the XXS garmented dyed long sleeve tees and muscle tees (and find that they are still loose on the body). I took three different sizes of this polo shirt into the change room, XXS, XS and S. The S was the best fit, being not too tight or too big. The others were way too small/snug. The body of the shirt does not look that slim on the hanger, but it turns out to be surprisingly slim fitting. Sizing issues aside, once you find your correct size, it is a classic versatile piece and a great deal on sale -some reviewers even recommend sizing up 2 sizes. I only sized up one size (and I think I would have been swimming in the medium) , but some people do like their fit looser.
August 5, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by Charmayne A nice easy go to
I bought the blue a week ago and have now washed it - it's not as "lived in" looking as the picture - quality is good, but the sizing it a tad on the slim side - the medium was fitted and the large was too big in the back - so I am hoping after a few wears that it stretches out a bit having gone with the medium.
June 20, 2016