Rated 3.3 out of 5 by 15
Rated 1 out of 5 by eld2016 A large, pilly mess
I bought this dress in red in a medium and I was swimming in it. (For reference, I'm 5'6" and about 130 pounds.) I tried to give it some shape by wearing a belt but that didn't help at all. I paired it with a wide black belt and fortunately before leaving the house, I realized that I looked like Santa Clause and quickly changed. I then ordered the dress in a small and it was not much better. The dress still looked big but I kept it. A few hours after wearing it for the very first time, it had started pilling a lot particularly under my arms. The dress didn't look new anymore. It was really disappointing and I've found that recently all of the J.Crew sweaters I've purchased have developed pills soon after wearing them for the first time. J.Crew's quality has really declined. Their prices aren't cheap so the quality of their clothing shouldn't be either.
January 13, 2016
Rated 2 out of 5 by Whit Lots of pilling
I bought this dress in the red color and absolutely loved it when I first wore it. I wore it for Christmas and then again to work and after only 2 wears the dress was pilling like crazy and did not look good. I took it back to the store and they were happy to return it because of the condition it was in. It is a shame because it was really a great dress!
January 12, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by KJac24 All the charm of a potato sack
Although the grey color is beautiful, and I love the knit, this dress was a shapeless disaster on. For reference I'm 5'8" and 128 lbs. Bought a small, it was huge! Even a belt didn't help. It was so big, I don't think an XS would be much better. Back to the store it goes.
January 8, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by KLMercer Disappointed
I always LOVE everything I purchase from JCrew. I was disappointed in this dress. Although I thought it was going to be a little loose fitting it was swimming on me. I am usually an xs or size 2 and I ordered the XS and it seemed like an XL. So back it went. Too bad because I think if it was much more fitted (not skin tight) it would have been perfect.
January 8, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by KatieLeona Awesome Sweater Dress
I love this dress!! I had been patiently waiting for J.Crew to add some sweater dresses and I purchased this one the day I saw it online. I am 5'6", 128lbs and ordered the XS. I'm usually a S or M in tops and 2 or 26 in pants but for some reason the XS dresses always fit me. It falls right at the knees for me, just like it shows on the model. I have rather long arms and find tops are always short in the sleeves but this fit rather well. So far I've worn it with tights and my Lowell knee high boots and leggings with my Sperry by J.Crew boots and love it!
January 9, 2016