Rated 3.3 out of 5 by 8
Rated 1 out of 5 by Mayma What's Goin' On?
I'm a truly devoted longtime J.Crew customer. You've been my relied upon go-to for so many many many classic wardrobe staples over many many years - and now I've discovered that something's going on. I've read other reviews and have found that it's not just me. This is the second cashmere sweater that I've sent back in as many months. The quality I depend upon isn't there and the fit just isn't up to what it used to be or should be - or what I've some to count on from J.Crew. I do appreciate that you need to stay current and want to refresh your old standards - and I'm among your older hip customers to be sure - but some of us out here WANT your classics in all those fabulous colors and styles (where else would I go if it's not at J.Crew?) and we are missing them. Don't lose us in the rush to update things.
May 12, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Bluesers Is it really cashmere?
When I received this item, I immediately double-checked the tag to make sure I received the correct item as this feels nothing like cashmere. The cashmere quality at J.Crew has seemingly declined for awhile now, but this is definitely the worst cashmere piece I have ever purchased from any retailer. It is not at all soft the way featherweight cashmere should feel. I compared it to a featherweight cashmere tee I purchased last spring, and it doesn't feel as soft (and to be honest, that piece wasn't even that great of quality). The fit is small for being boyfriend fit - it fit more like the long sleeve cashmere tee through the torso.
I purchased it in navy, and in the right lighting, it is sheer enough that I would be uncomfortable wearing it without a cami underneath.
Coming from someone who used to be obsessed with J.Crew's cashmere, this really is the biggest disappointment yet. You can do better, J.Crew.
April 30, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Chrissy Short and fitted
I almost think I received the wrong sweater. It came to my waist, and was fitted. Almost like a tippi sweater with longer sleeves. Not a boyfriend fit at all. I ordered the v neck boyfriend and the contrast is unbelievable. Returned this item and was extremely disappointed
May 1, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by mandymatt Nice Sweater
I like the featherweight cashmere as I find the classic cashmere sweaters too warm for living in San Francisco. I ordered the boyfriend sweater because I love my grey classic boyfriend but I found this to fit much smaller. With the classic I wear a medium and could borderline go for a small for a cleaner look. In this sweater the medium was fitted. I'm reordering in a large in hope that the size isn't completely off. The cashmere was dreamy soft.
June 1, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Valerie It's actually perfect for all seasons.
I first bought the periwinkle one then the black probably need grey too. It's the softest sweater I've ever had. My new best friend.
July 8, 2016