Rated 3.7 out of 5 by 33
Rated 2 out of 5 by ELLEN NOT LIKE THE OLDER VERSION
Just received this "incarnation" of the cashmere tee. If not for the color, the tee would be going back. The quality of the cashmere is inferior to the cashmere tees I have, at least five. The sweater is not as soft nor is it the same gauge. The neckline is constructed completely different. For reference have a look at the cashmere tee offered on the sale page and then compare the photo to the above sweater. I'm glad I already own the previous seasons tees in black, 2 shades of gray, and snow. Why J Crew would make changes to an already great sweater is perplexing.
August 12, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by Margot hmmm......
I have 10-12 of the short sleeve cashmere tee shirts from previous seasons.
In previous seasons, the sizing was erratic- I wear a small in some colors and a medium in others (I am 5'-9" and wear between a 4 and 8 in tops, depending on how it is made).
I decided to order a medium.
I tried it on and it looked fine from the front (slightly fitted) but from the side view there is a decent amount of fabric on the back just "puffing out" from my shoulder blade down to bottom of the shirt- so a frumpy look :(
The shape of the shirt is also different than before; before, the shirt had a slight indention at the waist with a very mild flare from the waist to the bottom of the shirt so it was a (very mild but noticeable) feminine silhouette; Now- the shirt is straight with no feminine shape and the bottom "hem" is slightly more narrow than the waist of the shirt- overall a kind of boxy look.
September 23, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by Susan Disappointing
The neckline is no longer the cute rolled neckline, it's just flat knit. Ruins the look of the whole sweater. I used to buy one of these every year. But there's nothing special about them anymore.
January 7, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by Lynn Different
Beautiful bright color.... Sweater is boxy and loose fitting. Material is thinner than previous years.
November 17, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by BorntoRhone Great colors as usual but needs some change
I have several cashmere tees and shells - living in Texas I have very limited use of the long sleeve cashmere sweaters. As noted by other reviewer this tshirt has changed somewhat, but without I have wanted for 5 years i.e. they never make V-neck or ballet neck or true scoop neck in either short or sleeveless cashmere. These shapes only appear with long sleeves. I would buy way more if they would fix the currently boring shape.
August 20, 2015