Rated 4.7 out of 5 by 86
Rated 4 out of 5 by jvk44 Comfy and stylish
I purchased these in black suede. They were comfortable right out of the box and all day after wearing them for 10 hours. Much more comfortable than the Valentina which cuts me across the top of the foot.
I wear a 7 in the Valentina and Elsie, but 6-1/2 in the Collette fits perfectly.
My only criticism is the man made sole. I do not understand why J Crew is starting to make their higher end shoes without leather soles. Certainly the prices have not gone down as a result!
August 16, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by teekizz yes, I have nice shoes but...THESE ARE AMAZING.
Bought them in black last week. Going back to order the nude color, although I am thinking about the poppy too.
These are Italian Masterpieces for your feet. They are a flattering comfortable cut, and fit better and wear better than my (much) more expensive pairs. I want them all.
I do not think they fit large, personally. But I think people are used to poorly fitting shoes (too tight/pinching)...these heels do not pinch. The slight asymmetrical toe box cut out is part of the reason that I have worn them ALL DAY without discomfort. It allows the flex without that usual above toe pinch.
Please do yourself a favor and just get them --- you won't be sorry. (I am super shoe and bag picky...and this workmanship, materials and design are CLASSIC)
August 7, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by shoelovvah LOVE!
Was thrilled to find these in store over the weekend - exactly what I've been looking for!! The asymmetrical cut is interesting and actually more beautiful in person. The heel height is (for me) relatively low, thereby tempering the sexy color (red) and making them more work appropriate. I'm in love! Just one note: I'm pretty predictably an 8.5 in most pumps, even J.Crew ones, and was surprised to find that an 8 was right for me in this shoe. The 8.5 was definitely too big.
July 21, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by HellaBella Great but not perfect
These are fantastic pumps, however I would not (and did not) pay full price for them due to the synthetic soles. I don't understand why the Elsie pump, at a similar price point, has a leather sole while the Colette does not. It's almost like J.Crew is making us pay more for the angled vamp in return for a cheaper outsole. These ran about half a size large for me and I have wide feet. The vamp is also bunion-friendly and the height is perfect. I hope that J. Crew will make these with leather soles in the future!
November 10, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by fashionaddict Nice Red Shoes
I normally wear size 8 but based on a review I ordered the 7.5 size but they are small and I am returning them to get my normal size. I love the red color given that red is really popular this fall.
August 7, 2015