Rated 2.8 out of 5 by 4
Rated 5 out of 5 by Squash Soo comfortable!
I am giving these 5 stars because they fit my feet perfectly and are so comfortable. I have wide feet, so finding shoes that are cute and comfortable is a never-ending challenge. These are not stiff and feel very nice to walk in.
September 21, 2016
Rated 2 out of 5 by Kelsey Runs wide, even for Gemmas!
When I saw these shoes, I fell in love and HAD to have them. I ordered them in my standard 6 (I have 4 other pairs of Gemmas, all size 6). I just received them today and they are HUGE! Even without any wear, and they will stretch, these shoes are too big - I have an insert in and they are still a concern. Plus, while the Gemmas run wide, these run VERY wide. I cannot foresee these fitting many feet well. Additionally, the cap toe is cut at an odd angle, making my feet appear MUCH wider than they are (my other Gemmas are svelte, so this is a surprise). I want to love these, but seeing as the 5 1/2 is sold out, they will be returned, not exchanged. Disappointed!!!!
September 23, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by Blossom So Cute, But Very Wide
I have several Gemmas. This one is much, much wider than the others. I like the look, so I am keeping it; however, I will need a shoe filler. I know it is crazy to pay that much for a shoe that doesn't fit well.
September 23, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Jill Cheap
I am very disappointed in this shoe. Poor quality construction and about 2 sizes too large in both length and width. The wool backing is flimsy and the toe is not suede capped as it appears in the picture. I was hoping these could be a great fall transition shoe. I have been buying JCrew for almost 20 years and they have obviously become a mass production brand searching for quantity over quality when it comes to factory distribution.
September 25, 2016