When James Colarusso isn't sculpting or building furniture from scratch in his converted Brooklyn carriage house, he works (by hand) on his eponymous collection of jewelry. Taking cues from his Sicilian roots, his lovingly crafted designs often have a talismanic feel—think lucky 13s and protective charms. Superstitions aside, these are the timeless, substantial pieces you cherish forever (and reluctantly pass down after a few decades). This simple gold ring is stamped with Colarusso's signature lucky 13. Even luckier? It goes with everything in our jewelry box.