Rated 4.2 out of 5 by 6
Rated 3 out of 5 by MeghanODB Just alright
I was desperately looking for a high quality, but natural and organic mascara. I love several RMS products and was excited to try this. However, it does not work as a volumizing mascara. It does a nice job of lengthening, and the color is a nice black, but its very liquid-y and can smudge easily when you first apply if you're not really careful.
May 15, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Jan1 Natural mascara
The RMS Volumizing mascara has not clumped so far which I have found to be a problem with some natural mascara. Unfortunately, I don't find it volumizing, it simply looks natural. However, applying two coats does help it look more like I'm wearing mascara and is much better. I wish it added volume but overall am happy for a natural mascara.
June 23, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by ProductJunkiesRehabBlog Best mascara!
And it's all natural! Couldn't be more pleased. RMS is awesome!! Thanks, JCrew, for carrying a natural brand. Spread the word!
May 23, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Emily Perfect in every way
I love all rms products and have been I religious user since the line first launched. I was nervous to try their new mascara because while I use products that are as natural as possible on my body, I was concerned a natural mascara may run or flake. This mascara is better than any chemically loaded brand I have ever tried (and I am a mascara lover and heavy user). Natural and high functioning, perfect!
September 18, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Marina Will not flake for over 12 hours!
I'll admit, I initially ordered this mascara to qualify for free shipping on the rest of my order. There, I said it. I did not know anything about the RMS products.
When it arrived I figured I might as well try it. Wow! What an exceptional mascara. The quality really surprised me and it literally stayed on without flaking from 6 am to 9 pm. I have never tried a mascara that did not flake at all. This one was the first. No flaking and no smudging. No more black dust particles under my eyes.
Additionally, even though it is not advertised as waterproof I showered while wearing it and it did not smudge.
I will agree with the other reviewers that it is not a volumizing mascara. It works well for daily use and has a lengthening effect while being natural.
Thank you J Crew for offering this exceptional product! I love it and wish it was offered in a shade of Blue.
February 20, 2015