Rated 4.2 out of 5 by 75
Rated 2 out of 5 by dexter perfect shirt BUT poor quality
I have probably purchased at least 8 of these shirts in 2 sizes (one neater fit other more casual) and have returned at least 4 of the shirts as they tear in the underarm or arm area. Today I noticed a big rip under right arm --usually okay until after 2nd washing then show embarrassing fabric weakness. Each time I have returned ( a nuisance) I am told that they are aware of this issue and in fact store sales staff have told me they also experienced same situation. Very frustrating so I will now buy a quality jean shirt and return this most recent one with the tear. I do have a few with little wear and no tear as yet.
July 21, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by SimpleChic Year-round Wardrobe Essential
This shirt comes soft and faded, like it's been your favorite shirt for years. The fit is slim through the body and arms. I'm 5'6" 117# and take a 2 in most JC tops. This 2 is slim-fitting, and even pulls slightly at the chest button (and my chest isn't big). I'd suggest going with your usual size if you plan to layer sweaters over it or tuck in, or size up for a larger chest or a casual untucked-with-leggings look. Washes and dries well. Edges need touch-up with steamer/iron.
May 15, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by blacknwhite smaller cut than old shirt?
i had this same exact shirt for years in a size 2 and finally wore it out so decided to buy a new one. although it's same cut and size it feels smaller across the back, that i might rip it if i stretch my arms out. unfortunately i already wore it so have to keep it, wishing i didn't ditch my oldy but goody!
May 6, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Mosie Great shirt, but shrinks in the dryer!
I absolutely love this shirt. It's so soft and easy to wear. However, I accidentally put it in the dryer and it shrunk and now fits too tightly. So if you like the way it fits, don't put it in the dryer!
July 10, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by lonestarlady Loved it until it fell apart
This was my absolute favorite shirt until the material literally deteriorated and several small holes formed. I treated this shirt gently -- laundering it in cold water on the gentle cycle and hanging to dry. It was as if the material just rotted and then fell apart. Considering the price point, I expected it to be an item that lasted. So, although it is a very versatile and great-looking shirt, I cannot recommend it due to the poor quality.
October 29, 2014