Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 8
Rated 2 out of 5 by ItalGal RUNS SMALL but nice if they fit...
I wear a size 28 in J. Crew's Lookout high rise jeans. After reading the mixed reviews, I ordered the 29 and just barely squeezed into them. Tried size 30 and they're too big, complete with dropped crotch. The sizing is so hard to get right without trying them on that I'd hesitate to buy them on final sale. The gap between Point Sur sizing and the rest of J. Crew's denim is not okay in my book. You should be able to buy the same size consistently from the same manufacturer. Go big or go small, I don't care, but pick one. For reference, I wear size 6-8, my hips are 38" and I have a tall straight build.
These have stretch but it's not the super soft stretchy pajama feel that some skinny jeans have. The denim is still fairly thick. The fading on this wash has a yellowish tinge in person that wasn't apparent on my computer.
February 7, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by CoryC77 Terrible fit
So I've already purchased the same jeans in the same color in a size 28 and like them but I wear them weekly but I feel like sometimes they're a little snug in the waist upon first wear post-wash. When I saw them go on sale so I ordered a 29 in the same underground wash. I received them today and the color washes are completely different even though the name is the same. What I received today has a ton of extra fading on the backside and the quad area. In addition they are EXTREMELY tight. How is it that the 29 I can't even come close to closing when the 28th fits me fine? And now because they were on sale I'm stuck with them due to final sale no returns. I'm really irritated about the inconsistency.
March 4, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by sassysue Fantastic jeans
These have become my favorite jeans. They are exactly how high-waisted jeans should be: perfectly fitted, sit on the smallest part of the waist, and make one's rear look good. The color is good, material is high quality, and they are simply fantastic. The legs are narrow, but they need to be.
November 18, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lydia Man everybody on here scared me about the fit...
I ordered a size up and they are a little loose. My regular size would have been perfect. Also, they are not as skinny or tapered as I wish they were around the ankles and look more like a straight leg jeans on me. Despite this, they are my new favorite jeans and I will probably buy again. They have stretch and are very comfortable to wear. I am 5'7 110 lbs and typically wear a size 26. I think highwaisted fits are a little bit trickier for more curvy girls but I don't think women with a straight shape should worry about sizing up in these.
April 11, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by zabl Love Point Sur Skinnies
I've had these jeans for a few months now so I can accurately tell you that they're one of the best pairs of denim I've ever owned and I've had my share of designer denim. The wash is perfect, just worn enough in the perfect shade of blue. The quality is top notch and miracle of miracles, they don't stretch out whatsoever! I have small kids and I'm doing a lot of bending and squatting and they look the same several hours into wearing them as they did out of the box. The piece de resistance is the rise - just perfect. They suck you in, accentuate your good curves and downplay the not so good. I'm 5'9", 165 and a 31" was perfect, if not a tad snug but in a good way. I typically vary from a 30" and a 31" in J.Crew denim. For what it's worth, the other washes in the Point Sur Hightowers (both skinny and straight leg) are fantastic too and sizing is similar from what I've found.
March 18, 2015