Rated 3.1 out of 5 by 11
Rated 4 out of 5 by CrewGirl Ok jean, color is a bit different than pic.
I ordered in a 26. I typically wear a 2 or 26 in JCrew pants and sometimes a 27 in skinny jeans. Considering they are supposed to be loose, I think they are true to other JCrew sizing. The waist is a tad big, and the waist rise is a bit long for me. I got in final sale, and I may be able to make them work. I was disappointed that the wash color is a little different than the picture. I chose these jeans largely because I thought I'd be getting a much darker colored faded denim. It's a brighter blue in real life, which I don't really like.
July 14, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by LeisureLady Great jean but inconsistent sizing
I love this jean for summer even though the size and length was very inconsistent. The size 29 was a bit big in the waist but the size 28 I ordered was too small in the waist and at least 1" longer. So I ordered another 28 which fits in the waist but is a bit short. Given the cute style and nice wash I kept the shorter pair which is still very cute rolled up. The waistline/rise is a bit higher than my other J Crew jeans but not too high. Other than the size issues, I love this jean.
May 15, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by seedubs great jeans but run big
I'm normally a 26 in J. Crew's Matchstick jeans. I ordered the Boyfriend jeans in the same size thinking that the waist would fit but that the overall cut would be more generous. Unfortunately, the waist was huge and I had to return them.
May 20, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by jcrewgirl Vintage Straight Jean
I was excited to find a broken-in boyfriend in this wash, however, when the item arrived, I saw that it was actually a "vintage straight" jean simply re-marketed online as a "broken-in boyfriend" jean. I was very disappointed. The fit is a mid-rise straight leg "mom jean," not the trendy, loose-fitting boyfriend jean I had tried on in store. The color was very nice and the jean was a good quality, but not what I had expected at all. I hope that this was simply a mistake and would ideally like to exchange the jean for a better fitting, more accurately named item.
July 23, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Marlene Boyfriend Jeans
Run a little large, but that's not much of a problem in jeans that are supposed to be on the slouchy side. Comfortable and well made.
June 7, 2014