Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 13
Rated 4 out of 5 by Editor It's all about the neckline
The reason I own four of these T-shirts is the neckline - it's a decent scoop, low enough to elongate the neck and show a little collarbone, not low enough to show anything else. The vintage fabric is thinner than I would like, so I stick to darker or more vibrant colors to avoid see-through problems. I hover between a 4-6 in J. Crew tops and the S fit fine, not too tight. This T-shirt is a little too long for someone 5'4", but it's so thin, it doesn't matter if it bunches a bit at the bottom.
May 15, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Melanie New favorite T when bought on sale
I love these shirts, already own 3 and buying 3 more now. They do fit a bit loose, so I size down. I usually wear size S in the regular crew neck tissue T (5'3", 125#, 34B) got a XS in these shirts and it's the same fit. The cotton is thin, so I don't expect them to last more than a few seasons as has been the trend with "tissue" material from JCrew, expect holes to show up after a year or so. I got mine on a pretty good sale, I wouldn't pay full price. For the unique, classic, flattering style I haven't been able to find anything I like as much anywhere else.
May 29, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Momofone Love these tees
I have purchased many of these tees. They are very flattering, not too clingy and love the neckline. The colours are lovely. The only drawback is that they are thin and need to be treated a bit delicately for a tee shirt. However, I will continue to purchase them as long as they make this style!
May 14, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by LCTBQE fabric gets holes quickly
I've had this t-shirt for a few months, and after about a month of wear, I noticed it was starting to spring holes in the fabric. This also has happened with all 4 j.crew tissue tees that I've gotten recently--the quality of the jersey material has REALLY gone downhill. I follow all the wash instructions and take care of my things, but there are tiny holes all over the place. I've been a customer for years and this never used to happen. But, seems like the pricepoints have dropped too.
July 19, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by 1234 I don't think so
I read the great reviews and bought three. Anyhow, I don't think the quality is that great. They are very thin and soft but the T's are so thin that don't I think they will last more than a couple of months. Also, I am an xs in everything, especially JCrew but these tops are practically fitted on me. JCrew also has another version of this top for sale but they are VNeck and sleeveless. They run too small and the quality isn't so great. Waist of money.
June 25, 2014