Rated 4.5 out of 5 by 4
Rated 4 out of 5 by dime Sleeves too short
Love this piece and still wondering if I should re-order. It is beautiful in the beige color too. The beige really shows off the make of the piece but I love navy. My problem is the fit. It's big around the neck and a little skimpy in shoulder width. The sleeves were terribly short on me but I am tall so that may be the problem. I wish these collection pieces would be offered in tall or come with nice hems in both sleeves and length. I was between a small and a medium so could not justify the price for something that 'kinda' fit okay. I am 34b and 5 ft. 10...usually wear a small in J Crew. If you are average height and looking for a great semi tailored top that's different but elegant this is worth the money. It's timeless. Hope this is helpful.
July 17, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by greycatgirl Really nice, but could have been spectacular
Listen, this is a beautiful piece and I liked that it was not a super snug fit. My only complaint - I think it was overpriced. I also think it could have been spectacular and a "5" if they had chosen a different color. I bought the navy but the dark color does not really show off the beauty and quality of this piece...wish it had been light grey or maybe a beige or even something in the greens...loved the patches on the elbows. Still not 100% sure if I am keeping it due to the price....but keep the luxury pieces coming...
July 15, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by JCSD Cozy topper
This topper jacket is beautiful. The material is super soft cashmere. I would rather have it button down the front instead of over the head. Still the perfect piece to go with tee shirt and jeans or blouse and slacks.
October 28, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Anne Just Gorgeous
I bought this piece in camel when J.Crew first offered it in 2011 and have consistently received compliments on it ever since. I'm not always impressed by the quality of J.Crew pieces; even Collection pieces tend to leave me wanting more both style- and quality-wise. This piece, however, is just gorgeous. The cashmere fabric is thick and soft and feels expensive, and the style and cut of this piece are beautiful, just as in the image of the item on the model. Although I typically think J.Crew prices a bit high for the quality, I would pay the labeled price for this item again in a heartbeat.
March 13, 2015