Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 50
Rated 2 out of 5 by MainlineGirl Big let down
I've been buying jcrew shoes for years and I hate to say it- I'm very disappointed. I never write reviews but it's tough to find a sleek street riding boot and I thought these would be winners. The color is beautiful, however the leather is very stiff and the fit is so bulky. The boot is way too loose around the ankle and leg, they fit like wellies. I think jcrew should go back to their previous classic shoe designs and quality. I will be returning them.
September 5, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by Abby519 Beautiful Boot with Gaping Ankles
I was so looking forward to these sleek, narrow riding boots but was disappointed when I received them. The footbed fits great, but the leather around the ankle was gaping and buckling. The shaft of the boot fit me fine and was not too narrow, and the zipper up the back is beautiful, but the extra leather around the ankle looked silly. Tragic! I'm still searching for a classic J.Crew tall boot with a fitted ankle.
January 9, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by Savannah Holy Blisters
As much as I loved these boots in the store, once I received them in the mail I was quite disappointed. Within the first 30 minutes of wearing them, I had the worst blisters all over my feet. I thought it was just because they needed to be broken in, but unfortunately after a few times wearing them I am still almost in tears while walking in them. The zipper also seems to snag and has caught on my boots several times causing nicks in the leather. I wish I could have saved money and shopped around before buying.
November 19, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by WhitSav Beautiful Design, Poor Quality
The design is perfect, but the sole is hard plastic and the leather is cheap and thin. I would expect much higher quality for this price point. Quality has slipped across all crew products the last few years. This will be another one of my many returns. Starting to think it's not worth the effort of ordering since 80% of stuff goes back to due to poor quality or erratic sizing.
November 24, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by Gina Beautiful leather boots
I bought these boots in the classic tan leather... they are beautiful. The color is perfect and the leather is very nice. I love the simplicity of the boot as well. However, they are not perfect. They come up really high to just about mid-knee... which is a bit awkward. For reference, I am 5'5". I have 15" calves so I bought the extended calf version. They fit great over skinny jeans and socks. But because they come up so high, there is space around the boot and my knee. Unfortunately I will be returning mine. :(
September 5, 2014