Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 28
Rated 5 out of 5 by Flibbertygibbit Exquisite Calf Hair
I purchased the Saddle Black color in my typical Viv size (8) and they fit the same (for reference I take a 7.5 in the Everly, Elsie, Kiki, and Cece; 7 in the Seville Wedge espadrille)
The subtle color variance in the calf hair is gorgeous. Beautifully made and executed, everything you would expect from a "Collection" piece.
August 1, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by FromOneGirl Great "Neutral" Shoe
These shoes look great (and I'm not usually a fan of pointed toe flats)!
I have noticed, though, that most of my recent "J. Crew Collection" shoe purchases run about a half size larger than the "J. Crew" shoe. I typically wear a 8 1/2 (9 in premier designer shoes). I ordered these in an 8 1/2, but they fit more like a "J. Crew" 9. With the elongated toe box to accommodate the pointed toe, I'd rather not run the risk of feeling the squeeze in an 8, so I added an insert and kept the 8 1/2.
September 11, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by BonBon4 Beautiful but poor quality
I was so excited to get these, but after wearing them only twice, the calf hair has come off completely from the pointed toe tip and have started to look very "worn." I purchase almost all of my shoes, and my daughter's shoes, from J.Crew, but the quality of these are extremely disappointing, especially considering the price point - DEFINITELY wished they would have held up longer. Very disappointed. I gave them 2 stars because they are beautiful, but unless you only plan on wearing them for an hour at a time indoors, I do not recommend purchasing them.
November 14, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by Jenn Really Uncomfortable
I was so excited to get this pair of shoes. I wanted a chetah print and loved that this was a pointy toed flat verses the rounded toe.
Unfortunately I have found these shoes to be really uncomfortable. They run small and they are really stiff all over. I can't wear them for longer than a couple of hours without my feet killing me. I am very disappointed with the overall fit of this shoe and they were not inexpensive. Bummed that these shoes aren't what I had hoped they would be!!
November 23, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by noah3FreeSpirit Great, go-to flat to dress up or dress down
I purchased these [brown] flats online in a size 8, which I normally wear with J.Crew. I must say they are great. They are comfortable as soon as you put them on. Normally, with some delicate Italian made shoes, you have to 'break' them in first to really get a sense of comfort. I have a wide foot and these are perfect. I will say the quality control of the shoe is better when ordered off online. The same [brown] calf hair shoes sold in store had a quality issue where the seam on the top front was visible and the fur wasnt professionally sewn w/ attention to detail. The shoes mixmatched quality. However, I was very impressed with the quality of my online order when I inspected them upon arrival. Ive been waiting to purchase this print since last Fall. So glad I did!
October 13, 2014