Rated 3.2 out of 5 by 60
Rated 5 out of 5 by Alexia Beautiful Blue!
I have been looking for not-quite-navy flats for a LONG time and ordered these in the caravan blue. These beauties did not disappoint! The color is a beautiful saturated dark oceany blue. Love them.
Note on sizing: I am a size 10 normally, took an 11 in the J.Crew Viv flats, but took a 10.5 in these. So I would say they run a little small, and you should order up half a size if you have medium to wide width feet like me.
Also, for those of you concerned about toe cleavage, these have less toe cleavage than the Viv's. In fact they have practically no toe cleavage, as they are cut straight across the vamp.
August 8, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by fancynancy pretty but uncomfortable
I was really hopeful that these flats would be my dream come true, go-to shoe, but they have fallen short. They look nice but they just do not break in. After months of wearing they are still stiff and create blisters with every wear. Really disappointing especially given the price.
October 2, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by fablifeforever beautiful but painful
I purchased these shoes in the cabernet color - they are a beautiful burgundy shade and are a sleek looking flat. I took my usual size in J.Crew shoes in these. Out of the box they seemed like they would be comfortable but quite the contrary - perhaps I need to break them in more but they are incredibly painful in the toe box area - with the shape of the toebox being squared off it rubs against my feet terribly. So I wear these when I'll be mostly sitting unfortunately. I find the Viv flats to be much more comfortable and the calf hair version of the Harper flats are also more comfortable.
October 30, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by Skate Squeaky!
Wanted to love these--they look great and are versatile enough for work or play, skirts or pants. But they are loud! These shoes make loud squeaky noises when I walk! Going back.
September 18, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jeanine Sexy Flats
These flats look so sleek and polished. I loved the pointed toe and fit. These shoes look great from the office to a happy hour, truly chic. I bought the black pair and I am definitely going to purchase the soft desert next.
Note, the vamp looks square on the picture, which almost made me not buy the shoe. The vamp looks truly more rounded and flatters the toes.
September 4, 2014