Rated 4.5 out of 5 by 74
Rated 5 out of 5 by MissMEW OMG!
I have been looking for the perfect loafer and now my search is over... this is the loveliest, most comfiest (;o) shoe ever. And the colors -- stunning. Like all J.Crew shoes they run true to size width-wise, which is to say that if you have a slightly wider foot (or bunions -- I'm sorry, I have to mention them every time! they rule my life), you might consider ordering your own size and a half size up. I find the true size works best in cooler weather, whereas a half size up is better for warmer weather when feet tend to swell a bit. Here's a good trick though for getting them to fit perfectly: put on thick socks and apply a hairdryer heat to the problem areas; wear the shoes (with the socks still on) till they cool -- they will have stretched perfectly to your foot widths. Stock up!
June 5, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by katohnine Most comfortable shoes ever
I own two pairs of the Cleo loafers and plan to have a third very soon. These truly are the most comfortable shoes I've ever put on my feet and I had foot surgery four months ago. They come in great colors, go with just about everything and have an easy classic look. I have no complaints at all about these shoes and even like the fact that they tend to run a little large.
May 22, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by loaferlove beautiful but…
lovely shoes. they look and fit great BUT they are 'squeaky'!! without exaggeration they are the noisiest shoes. i am hoping they'll improve once they are broken in but at the moment every step is very noisy… awkward walking in a quiet room…
May 15, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Betsy The Perfect Loafer
I bought the black suede loafer. I plan on wearing them with narrow ankle or capri pants or jeans. They are VERY comfortable, and fit true to size. The same style in linen stripe were a little wide on me, and had to be returned.
May 14, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by STACEBOOK Perfection.
These are amazing! I have been wanting some J.Crew loafers for awhile (right mix of quality + style), but haven't been able to put out for the triple digit price. I bought these on a whim during a random sale, due entirely to the positive reviews, so I figured I better pay it forward! They have never rubbed/required band aids or socks, they have not caused blisters, they have accommodated my swelling feet in the summer. They even went through wet, freshly cut grass and still came away unscathed once dry. I wear them with cuffed denim, black skinny pants, shift dresses, literally everything. They're the best - I want them in every color!
July 22, 2014