Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 27
Rated 3 out of 5 by schnooks Sizing is a problem
For JCrew cardigans, both cashmere and merino, the sizing is problematic. I usually take a small, but these have been rather snug at least in some colors -- some have fit ok. I have sent for mediums and find that some fit ok but others seem too big. There seems to be no consistency. Otherwise, the cardigan sweater is nice if you can get the right fit, but it seems to be on a garment by garment basis. This makes ordering the items rather tedious.
August 21, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Millie Great jacket substitute, size/fabric inconsistent
I purchased this sweater in expresso and the fit was perfect, cashmere is very soft and thick. A few days later, I ordered the same sweater in black ... it arrived today, much more snug than the first cardigan and the cashmere is so thin and flat napped, it really looks and feels like merino, a big disappointment! I would love to have more colors in this sweater, but the inconsistency in colors is going to make ordering rather difficult.
September 8, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by DixieDiva Awesome cashmere cardi
I have never bought clothes from J Crew as they don't go up to my size. However, this fabulous cashmere cardi was sized up to XXL with a "relaxed fit" so I took a chance. It. Is. Amazing. The roasted acorn color is so beautiful for Fall. The cashmere is seriously luxe and it was on sale! The advertised relaxed fit made the XXL the perfect size, although not nearly as relaxed as on the model. There are many of us out there, over size 16, who love the J Crew look. It's an untapped, underserved market waiting for a savvy retailer.
September 11, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Spaz Great cardigan
This is a great cardigan! I like it because it's soft and stylish. I also like the length...perfect, hits right at the hip. You can also button this closed if you want. Other cardigans I have from JCrew I can't always button closed. This is also a warm cardigan...lovely and practicable. I bought it in gray and navy.
October 23, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by happygal soft but a tiny bit tiny.
I really like it, just runs a bit small. I recommend buying a size up.
October 15, 2014