Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 38
Rated 5 out of 5 by katohnine Comfortable and flattering at the same time
I have two of these (navy and ivory) and hope to get more colors for the summer as this top is extremely comfortable and will look great with just about everything. It's not clingy at all and drapes really nicely so if you have any little bulges, not to worry - you'll look fit and trim. I also feel it runs a bit on the large side as I generally wear a medium in J Crew tops and a small was perfect, still giving me enough room for a nice, loose look. I think this top would flatter most any figure.
June 4, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Crewgirl Nice quality but sloppy fit & execution
I wanted to love this shirt. The colors are great, the material is soft and light and I love the style. However, each sleeve folds up - and does not stay up. So the extra material just sort of flaps, especially in the back. It does not stay folded and just hangs there looking messy and sloppy. The folds stick out like wings in the back. I bought one in a bunch of colors, but now I am debating perhaps keeping one or two and maybe putting in a stitch to keep the folds folded. A little disappointed. Also, definitely size down in this shirt. I am a XXS in J.Crew, and I find the XXS in this shirt to be really big (especially the armholes).
June 25, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by whatthemom Comfortable on Trend Muscle Tee
I love this NON-SHEER tee. I bought the navy and the light gray and both are not sheer and can be worn alone. I am 5'8 34A and normally wear 2 on top and the XS in this is actually a little big/drapey on me. It is also long. I could possibly size down to XXS but I like the drape of the larger fit. This material makes it look a little dressier than just a plain tee and can be dressed up/down. The arm holes are small enough to not show too much bra. Mine does peek a little bit but not too bad. The one thing I don't love is the rolled cuff because it wants to unroll itself and not stay put.
June 24, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by kaihoku Runs large, extremely loose
I liked the idea of this tank and it would probably feel great on a hot summer day. Unfortunately even in an XXS it was too large for me. I am 104lbs, 5'. It also has no shape and is very loose fitting.
June 28, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by Sara Flawed sleeve design
I wanted to love this - and there is much about it to love (size, shape, material), but the fold-up sleeve is a disaster. The fold is sewed down at the shoulder and under the arm, but the fold doesn't stay down at all in the front and the back; it flaps loosely and just looks silly. Even a good ironing doesn't really keep it down. Maybe if you had it dry-cleaned and starched.....Very disappointing.
July 13, 2014