Rated 2 out of 5 by 2
Rated 2 out of 5 by Maddie Giant!
I thought this sweater would be a safe bet, but I was wrong. I usually order an Xs or S, but tend to stick with a S for sweaters because it allows for layering. I ordered the S and it is HUGE. Seriously I think someone who normally orders a large could wear this. I'm not sure if there is any way that I can make this work. If you order it, do yourself a favor and size down. I will say that the sweater is extremely soft and comfortable. It would make for a cozy sweater, just size down to avoid looking sloppy.
October 15, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by VirginiaW Agreed with the other review - Huge.
This picture on the model looks fantastic - kind of boxy, but fitting on her. I purchased a small, thinking it would be a medium. Instead, I feel like it's a L, and I feel XXL in it - It's enormous, and even when I half tuck it, the shoulders and sleeve openings are so large that it looks like I'm wearing pads underneath. I would say an XS is probably fitting for someone who is a true Medium to look like the photo above - I'd venture to say this sweater is easily 2x the size. A size Small for J.Crew is "a perfect fit" for me, but a M in J.Crew is what feels right - slouchy, cool, but not really "oversized." This sweater is awkwardly oversized. Kind of disappointing since it was Final Sale and non returnable.
February 7, 2015