Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 208
Rated 2 out of 5 by DLYNN Half the Jackie she used to be
I am so saddened by this cardigan. I have a burnished olive Jackie from 4 years ago that I adore and wear all the time. It has required mending around the neck twice, but overall has held up beautifully. I like it so much I decided to pick another up in a sensible navy, but..... The fabric is much thinner. It also doesn't bounce back like my earlier model; the elbows were stretched out and baggy at the end of its first day. Even the buttonholes are sub par - they're so small that when I was unbuttoning, one of the buttons snapped in half as I struggled to force it through the unwilling buttonhole with my SUPER HUMAN STRENGTH (#sarcasm). I guess I really need to chill with my exuberant button wrangling and cardigan removal tactics.
August 5, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by cspel25 classic cardi
I probably have the Jackie Cardigan in 12 colors--love it. But, as I unbuttoned my newest navy cardigan for the first time after it arrived, one of the buttons broke off in my hand. Really disappointing, as some of the Jackies I've had have lasted for years.
May 10, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Tenaflyrobin Buttons poorly sewed on
I love JCrew and my closet shows it. 80% of my clothing is JCrew, and I've been a loyal customer for 20+ years. The Jackie cardigan is a great basic, but the buttons are VERY poorly attached and not well made either. I have had to reattached buttons 3 x in less than a month. Also, the second time I washed a cardigan one of the buttons broke either in the washer or dryer...not sure which. I always wash JCrew on gentle.
May 15, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by KimK Classic Piece, Poor Quality
The Jackie Cardigan is one of my favorite pieces from J. Crew. I can pair it with everything. However, each time I order a new one, one of the buttons falls right off when I take it out of the package. I'm tired of sending them back, but I don't like having to pay for getting the button fixed.
May 15, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by LHBoston Cute Cardigan- on the short side
A nice cardigan for spring with great colors. It fit a bit smaller than the Tippi Cardigan and hit the top of my hip (I am 5'-5"). Wish it were a bit longer, but overall I like the style.
May 9, 2014