Rated 4 out of 5 by Chickie Watch Out For the Boob Button
I have 3 striped shirts from J Crew, so of course I needed a 4th. Love the shirt except for the buttons! So weird. They're smaller than normal buttons and the button holes are a little too loose. How embarrassing to have the "boobage button" inconveniently pop-open when my goal was to hide (not flaunt) the girls. Otherwise, it's another good J Crew shirt.
May 14, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by laurnadoone22 The perfect fit for tall women!
Love this shirt, and have nearly all the colors and striped and patterned ones in it as well. J Crew, will you please make more of the stretch 3/4 sleeved perfect fit one in additional stripes, colors, plaids, patterns etc? As well as also make it in short sleeve, too? For reference, I am 5'10", 135 lbs, have a 34c bust and wear all of these in a tall small. Also, the sleeves on the long sleeve are almost too short after washing, please add maybe a 1/2 inch of fabric to the end of them? The length in the body is perfect for me though!
May 27, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by GrendelsMom Perfect, indeed!
I've been searching for ages for a button-down shirt that fits as well as J. Crew's Perfect Shirt! The overall fit is very slim--there's no extra fabric around the waist or arms, making it easy to tuck into a pair of pants or wear underneath a cardigan sweater. Although I have wide shoulders, my regular size (XS/2) fit perfectly. I liked this shirt so much, in fact, that I've already purchased a few solid colors, too. Now if only it came in a sassy red stripe...
August 3, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by archaeoK Stylish and cut beautifully
Stylish, beautifully cut shirt. I usually don´t go for button downs because they are so boring, but this shirt is an exception. I am a size 4 in JCrew shirts. I am slightly built and lean on top (32B) and rarely find shirts off the rack that fit well (not a fan of the boxy cut). This shirt fits like it was tailored with my body in mind and is so flattering. The thin crisp stripe adds dimension and a bit of edge. The cotton is high quality. Wore with black curator pants, and it looked effortless, stylish and sexy. Glad I took the chance on this button down.
July 31, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by Naners Poor quality, wore out in 18 months
I purchased this shirt 18 months ago. Since then, I've used it lightly and always washed it according to the instructions. However, the fabric around both arms has worn out, leaving two tears that make the shirt unusable. I'm very disappointed - this is not the quality I expect from JCrew, or from a shirt at this price point.
June 18, 2014