Rated 4.7 out of 5 by 6
Rated 4 out of 5 by chicnyc Cute collar
The collar ads a bit of interest. This is a slimmer fit that a lot of their button downs. I opted for a larger size.
August 22, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by KCCrewShopper Super cute, runs small
I bought this shirt at my local store, and I'm glad I saw it in person. It's much cuter than online. I love the collar style, the weight of the fabric, and the beautiful rhubarb color.
I'm also glad I got to try it on in the store. I typically wear a size 4 in J. Crew shirts, and it's almost always a little too big...but a 2 is slightly too small. (Maybe I'm a size 3??) This shirt in my regular size was super small for me. I ended up with a 6, which fits just right. I'd definitely recommend sizing up.
September 2, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by BlackSharpie Love the collar, fits smaller than past boy shirts
I bought this shirt right away because of the collar, and I wasn't disappointed. It is very cute and looks just like the picture. This isn't a formal dress shirt but it is plenty good enough for work. The cotton is thin but still somewhat crisp.
J. Crew's boy shirts used to fit large for me (at least the ones from earlier this year and last year) but not this time. I'm 5'5"/110lbs and I usually wear 00 in boy shirts and 0 in other tops. I bought the 00 this time, but the sleeves are tighter than my other boy shirts, and the body is a bit slimmer. I'd say this boy shirt fits true to size. I don't need to return the 00, but the sleeves are just barely wide enough for my skinny arms.
August 30, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by LDiane Cute shirt, but not me
Cute shirt, but not me. I'm a size 8 in tops, and ordered a size 10 as some reviews said it ran small. The size 10 was way too big.
September 13, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by kmarie perfectly basic
This shirt has a nice slim fit. Sleeves are long enough for someone with slightly longer than average arms for height. While sold as "Navy" to my eyes this is black gingham (which is what I wanted). Definitely a dark navy.
September 11, 2016