Rated 4 out of 5 by 1
Rated 4 out of 5 by JCrewAddict Inconsistent Sizing
I love the style. The pants look great on. Five stars for style.
I gave them three stars for quality because of inconsistent sizing. I ordered four pairs: P2 and P4, in both the black and the navy. The two pairs of navy pants, while they were labeled P2 and P4, both fit like a P4.
The two pairs of black pants, seemed to be correctly labeled. I could actually see and feel a difference when I tried the two sizes on. Turned out the P2 fit me best, so I kept the black P2. I would have liked to keep the navy P2 too... if they had actually fit like a P2. As a result, overall four stars.
For reference, I usually wear a J.Crew 0/P2 in more tailored bottoms and a 2/P4 in casual bottoms. I would say these fit true-to-size.
July 23, 2014