Reviews
Fits small based on
8 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 8 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Customers really appreciate the gorgeous design and attractive sale prices of these pumps. Many customers noted that the shoes run very narrow and recommended sizing up if you have wider feet, while those with narrow feet found them to fit perfectly. A few mentioned minor comfort issues like tighter straps or hard accents, though most found them suitable for both work and a night out. Overall, the stylish look and versatile wear make these heels a great value for customers with a narrow fit.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
AndyB17
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Fits small
Way too narrow
October 22, 2025Should’ve heeded the reviews. Gorgeous shoes but the width must be made for a child’s foot. I ordered two pairs of shoes off this site in my regular size, and they both are so extremely narrow that I can barely get my foot in them. I’ve never had a problem with my feet being too wide; don’t get me wrong, they’re not small, but they’re also not wide. These wouldn’t have fit even if I’d ordered a size up. Of course they’re final sale and unable to be returned so now I have to find someone who wears a 10.5 but has a foot the width of my 9-year-old’s.
Helpful?Response from J.Crew
October 23, 2025So sorry for the frustrations! We've been in touch.
love clothes too much
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 55 to 64Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 11Fits small
Happy I sized way up!!
July 26, 2025I really wanted a pair of navy heels. Thanks to other reviewers I sized way up and these fit!!!! Picture in reviews also made these cute shoes so much more appealing. I took a chance on ordering because the sale price was phenomenal! I'm usually a size range 9.5-10 with wide feet destroyed by decades of distance running. I often order 10.5 in heels and narrow shoes . I actually ordered an 11 in these based on reviews and they fit.So happy I ordered the black at an even better price!!!
Helpful?AbiK
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Size Purchased: 9Fits true to size
Great! But for narrow feet
May 3, 2025Arrived early! Great event/going out shoes and great quality. Got them on super clearance so certainly worth the price. But they fit so great because they are narrow shoes and I have narrow feet. I would steer clear if you do not have narrow feet (or size up). But for me, a size 9 fits true to size.
Helpful?CincyKate
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 45 to 54Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 10Fits true to size
Sexy and comfort in one!
February 5, 2025I've been looking for a sexy pair of heals in navy that were also comfortable for a long time. These pumps are appropriate for both work and a night out on the town.
Helpful?Anniebunny
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Fits true to size
Beautiful but painful.
January 18, 2025Gorgeous? yes, very narrow? also yes. Hopefully they will stretch with wear.
Helpful?Anna215
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Body type: Curvy on bottomHeight: 5'7"Size Purchased: 7Fits small
Elegant and well-made, but for narrow feet
January 10, 2025I bought despite reading the previous negative reviews b/c they were heavily discounted. (Love those end of year sales.) I'd been eyeing them because I was looking for a non-stiletto, black suede pump that would stay securely on my foot. I'm a size 7, bought a 7, and have a very narrow, bony foot with a high arch, and these fit my feet perfectly. I can see why this shoe would not fit feet that are less narrow or have lower-arches, though. I can easily walk a few blocks in them. The straps leave grooves in the skin, but they're soft and I didn't find this uncomfortable. No heels are comfy, let's be honest, but these are very well made and the least offensive ones I've tried in awhile. Worth the sale price for sure.
Helpful?