MacAlister shearling-lined suede boots

Sometimes J Crew colors are completely way off compared to online photos. This is definitely one of those times :) Per the other review, I was also expecting a lighter color and received I would say close to a chocolate color. As for the suede, I find it to be very soft and comfy. The soles feel great on foot. The color is off but I don’t mind it so much as the shoes still go with many different options. Happy to keep this. For me, the quality and fit makes up for the miscue on color…and it was also on sale. Still a great deal and a keeper

The other person who left a review is right, these are much darker in person than they are in the product photos. The shearling lining also isn't particularly high-quality, but if you can snag these on sale for $40 - 70 they are outstanding. They look cute and are SO comfortable. I wear a size 9.5D in Adidas, Asics, Grant Stone, Allen Edmonds, and J.Crew's Kenton shoes. With these I had to go down to a 9.0D, but at that size they fit like a glove.

The fit is as expected and true to size but the color was not. I was expecting a light grey/natural color but these are a very dark and drab gray and so is the shearling lining. I had bought a pair from JCrew about 8 years ago and they were much better in terms of style and better matched color preferences. My Size Comparisons: Converse Chuck Taylor size 9.5 Adidas size 10 Sorel size 10