Lightweight waffle base-layer henley

I bought this shirt in the ink shadow and ivory -- both are true to the colors pictured online. The shirt is flattering and I love the flexibility of wearing it snapped all the way up or not. It runs a little small, which I had read in the reviews. I generally wear an S, sometimes XS and sometimes M, and I bought this in M. There's plenty of room but it's not baggy. I wish I had discovered the shirt sooner so I could have bought more colors.

I purchased a medium and fortunate it was on sale but non-returnable. The sleeves are to short, fabric is kind of thin and the shirt is not fitted like a Henley shirt should be.

I got this in the blue ink color — based on the comments that it ran small, I wanted to size up to L but it sold out, so I went with my regular medium. It fits fine! I just ordered the same M size in olive green. I docked one star because the original price was a little too high for what it is. At the sale price, I feel better about getting another color. If more colors were available in M, I’d be stocking up!

Love. 120 lbs. 5'8. Bought small. A bit big, but truly love. Perfectly Soft but not bouncy jersey... thank goodness.

Have ordered several Henley's from Jcrew in the past, this one does not meet the quality standards I have come to expect from Jcrew. It's see-thru fabric makes it look cheap.

I wish I could return these. Right when I opened the box, I saw that the brilliant raspberry color isn't nearly as saturated as in the picture. It's also has fine horizontal stripes, which aren't pictured. The quality is no better than you'd get for far cheaper at a big box store, and even though I got these at a deep discount, I'd say they aren't worth the money. The fabric is thin and if you live in a place that gets "real" winter, these are far from an adequate base layer. I regret buying these on final sale, because now that I can see the pictures were very misleading, I'm still stuck with an item that's going straight to goodwill.