New Winona lug-sole penny loafers in Italian spazzolato leather
Fits true to size based on
Reviews
Fits true to size based on
16 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 16 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Most customers really love the loafers for their stylish, versatile design and overall comfort, making them a great pick for both casual and dressy looks. Many have noted that the shoes tend to run a bit big, with a few recommending ordering a half size down for the perfect fit. A couple of customers even mentioned that a slightly longer break‑in period might lead to brief discomfort at first, though this didn’t stop them from enjoying the look and feel of the shoe. Overall, the loafers are seen as a premium, chic option that adds a touch of sophistication to any outfit.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Curvy on bottomHeight: 5'9"Size Purchased: 9.5Fits true to size
Instant classic
2 weeks agoExcellent shoe. Classic in every way.
Helpful?chrico
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 45 to 54Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'4"Size Purchased: 7.5Fits true to size
Well made loafers
March 20, 2026These an excellent loafers. They look like higher priced shoes. The quality is superb. They fit true to size. My feet are a bit wide and they aren’t tight in my regular size. I have worn them once without blisters. They are pretty comfortable as well and look very stylish.
Helpful?mgkd
Age: 25 to 34Body type: HourglassHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 8.5Fits small
So cute!
March 19, 2026They're the perfect loafers looks-wise, just takes a while to break in and got blisters the first few times. Leather should be stretchier / soles could use a little boost. Ordered .5 size down and fit perfect.
Helpful?Tabby cat
Age: 55 to 64Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'2"Size Purchased: 9Fits big
Winona Lug Loafers looked used
March 14, 2026Have been looking for the perfect loafers for a while now. When I came across the Winona lug sole loafers I thought I’d found the perfect pair. Sadly when they arrived they were to big. Even if the sizing had been right, I could clearly tell they had been worn, as the inside back heel had staining.
Helpful?Response from J.Crew
March 16, 2026Sorry for the disappointment. Glad to see our team was able to help.
Debteacher
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 65 or overBody type: PetiteHeight: 5'0"Size Purchased: 9Fits big
Nice shoe. Good heel height.
January 10, 2026This heel height helps with slacks, especially if you are petite. Comfortable shoes. Very stylish.
Helpful?Sally k
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 65 or overBody type: TallHeight: 6'0"Size Purchased: 12Fits true to size
The best penny!!
October 28, 2025Did a pre-order for these beauties! LOVE LOVE them! Fit is extremely comfortable! Love the bit of shine on the leather! These penny loafers are worth EVERY SINGLE PENNY! Thanks JCrew!!!
Helpful?