Topcoat in Irish wool

Overall, I like this coat, but I wouldn't pay full price for it. I caught it on sale for $450 and that feels about right. I would agree with other reviewers that the heavily padded shoulders make the silhouette a little boxy, but I actually like the generous fit in the body and I especially appreciate the full length. The substantial fabric drapes nicely. I do wish the sleeves were cut with a similar allowance though, because they are more snug than I would like when I wear this over a suit jacket. They're fine over sweaters, however. My other complaint goes for a lot of J.Crew's clothing. They go through the effort to source quality fabrics, which is the case here, but then slap on the cheapest buttons they can find. They look acceptable from a distance, but up close you can see they are flimsy plastic with an unnaturally shiny finish. I do love the fabric, and I especially like the tartan print on the lining. To me, this is just a few tweaks shy of being worth their full asking price, but on sale it's a nice coat that I enjoy wearing.

Versatile coat to dress up or down. Great material.

Beautiful coat. This was a gift for my husband and he absolutely loves it. It's a beautiful well made overcoat and he will definitely get a lot of use out of it this NYC winter. My only complaint is that it is very large and shapeless, so it doesn't look quite as nice as I would prefer, but he absolutely loves it and prefers the more casual style that the shape provides. He will definitely be wearing it all winter long.

I bought this coat for the cold New England winters and so far it has provided warmth. I have wide shoulders so I purchased a 46L which was perfect for my arm and back, but it is slightly larger through the waist and legs. I will probably have it taken in a bit there, but overall a high quality well made coat.

It's nice coat with the wool/materials. However the fit, especially by the shoulders looks and feels off. I'm typically a size 42s for all my coats but I feel a 40s would fit better.

Bought this piece for my birthday this year and I’m overly satisfied with the fit and overall quality of this coat. Very cozy, very warm and extremely stylish. This coat will elevate any outfit whether dressed up or down. A very beautiful, functional and versatile coat.